ref: f388d888518486676931e0fc3bd915fbb8b338e3
dir: /PHILOSOPHY/
Chocolate Doom has been designed around a careful and deliberate
philosophy that attempts to recreate the original ("Vanilla") DOS
executables for Doom, Heretic, Hexen and Strife. This document
describes some of that philosophy and the reasoning behind it.
This document is descriptive, not proscriptive.
== Vanilla behavior ==
Ideally Chocolate Doom aims to recreate the behavior of the Vanilla
binaries, but different aspects of Vanilla behavior are held to
varying degrees of importance. It can be imagined as different "tiers"
of compatibility:
* The game and gameplay itself is of central importance. Here, the
Vanilla behavior ought to be maintained as accurately as possible.
This includes the look, feel and sound, and things like demo
compatibility.
* The surrounding aspects of the game that aren't part of the central
gameplay experience can be extended as long as there's a good
reason and Vanilla behavior is respected.
* The setup tool is not required to reproduce the behavior of the
Vanilla setup tool, even though it reproduces its look and feel.
"Vanilla" is defined as:
* DOS Doom 1.9 (although there are actually multiple "1.9"s).
* DOS Heretic 1.3.
* DOS Hexen 1.1.
* DOS Strife 1.31.
"Vanilla" does not include ports (either official or unofficial), such
as console ports, Doom 95 or Doom 3: BFG Edition.
== DOS tools ==
Chocolate Doom includes some features that aren't part of Vanilla Doom
but exist for compatibility with DOS tools that interact with it.
These are considered part of the Vanilla experience and ought to be
treated as such. Some examples are:
* The novert setting, which reproduces the functionality of
novert.exe.
* The -deh parameter, which loads Dehacked patches like dehacked.exe
does under DOS. Chocolate Doom imposes the same limitations that
Vanilla Dehacked does.
== Exceptions ==
Chocolate Doom differs from Vanilla Doom in a number of ways. In most
cases these are subtle, minor differences. Nonetheless they deserve
some explanation and justification. Here are some examples of
situations where changes are considered acceptable:
1. Vanilla behavior can be broken that is harmful, eg. can damage the
player's computer, or is just outright misleading. For example:
- Vanilla uses unbounded sprintf and strcpy (security issue).
- Vanilla has crashes that force the user to reboot the machine.
- Vanilla has an out of memory message that recommends tweaking
CONFIG.SYS. As Chocolate Doom doesn't run under DOS, reproducing
this message would not be helpful.
2. Subtly extending behavior is okay where it's not clear what the
Vanilla behavior is anyway. For example:
- Opening the menu releases mouse grab in Chocolate Doom.
- Chocolate Hexen's graphical startup screen runs in a window.
3. Supporting obsolete technology is not a goal: it's considered
acceptable that Chocolate Doom does not support every type of
hardware from 1993. However, Chocolate Doom should aim to recreate
the functionality in a modern way. Examples of technology that
isn't supported are:
- No support for IPX networks, but TCP/IP is instead.
- No support for dial-up/serial connections; modern operating
systems have features that do that for you.
- No MS-DOS version.
4. Changes are permitted that allow the player to be able play the
game. For example:
- There are new key bindings for actions that can't be rebound with
Vanilla Doom, because it's useful for portability to machines
that don't have a full keyboard.
- There are additional mouse or joystick key bindings that let you
perform actions with them that can only be done with the keyboard
in Vanilla Doom.
- Chocolate Doom includes some hacks to support the Doom 3: BFG
Edition IWAD files. The assumption is that being able to at least
play is better than nothing, even if it's not Vanilla behavior.
5. Adding extra options to Vanilla functionality is permitted as long
as the defaults match Vanilla, it doesn't change gameplay and
there's a good reason for it. For example:
- PNG screenshots are supported because PCX is an obsolete format.
- Chocolate Doom has the vanilla_keyboard_mapping option that
allows the user to use the native keyboard mapping for their
computer, rather than always assuming a US layout.
6. Changing configuration file defaults is permitted where there's a
very good reason. For example:
- Vanilla Doom defaults to no sound or music if a configuration
file is not found. Chocolate Doom defaults to having sound
effects and music turned on by default, because modern computers
support these; there's no need to configure hardware IRQ settings
to get sound working.
7. Things can be changed if they're really just inconsequential. For
example:
- The startup messages in Chocolate Doom are not identical to
Vanilla Doom and are not necessarily in the same order.
- Vanilla Doom has command line options named -comdev, -shdev and
-regdev used by id internally for development; these have been
removed.
A good litmus test of when it's acceptable to break from Vanilla
behavior is to ask the question: "Although this is Vanilla behavior,
is there anyone who would want this?".
For example, emulating Vanilla bugs like the visplane overflow bug is
something that is useful for people making Vanilla format maps. On the
other hand, painstakingly emulating Vanilla Doom by starting with no
sound or music by default is not helpful to anyone.
== Other philosophical issues ==
Chocolate Doom aims for maximal portability. That includes running on
different CPUs, different operating systems and different devices (ie.
not just a desktop machine with a keyboard and mouse).
Chocolate Doom is and will always remain Free Software. It will never
include code that is not compatible with the GNU GPL.
Chocolate Doom aims to be minimalist and straightforward to configure;
in particular, the setup tool should have a sane interface. Part of
the inspiration for Chocolate Doom came from Boom's complicated maze
of options menus (and a desire to avoid them). Too many preferences
lead to a bad user interface; see Havoc Pennington's essay on Free
Software UI:
http://ometer.com/free-software-ui.html
Chocolate Doom has some options that are quite obscure and only really
of interest to a small number of people. In these cases, the options
are hidden away in configuration files and deliberately not exposed in
the setup tool. The assumption is that if you care enough about those
obscure features, editing a configuration file by hand should not be a
huge problem for you.
# vim: tw=70