shithub: pokecrystal

Info • Files • Log • Branches
ref: 78d489733c8da46b901ecb47e82e2fc45498b387
dir: /docs/bugs.md/
# Bugs


## Belly Drum sharply boosts Attack even with under 50% HP

([Video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zuCLMikWo4Y))

This is a bug with `BattleCommand_BellyDrum` in [battle/effect_commands.asm](battle/effect_commands.asm):

```
BattleCommand_BellyDrum: ; 37c1a
; bellydrum
; This command is buggy because it raises the user's attack
; before checking that it has enough HP to use the move.
; Swap the order of these two blocks to fix.
	call BattleCommand_AttackUp2
	ld a, [AttackMissed]
	and a
	jr nz, .failed

	callab GetHalfMaxHP
	callab CheckUserHasEnoughHP
	jr nc, .failed
```

**Fix:**

```
BattleCommand_BellyDrum: ; 37c1a
; bellydrum
	callab GetHalfMaxHP
	callab CheckUserHasEnoughHP
	jr nc, .failed

	call BattleCommand_AttackUp2
	ld a, [AttackMissed]
	and a
	jr nz, .failed
```


## HP bar animation is slower with more HP

([Video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SE-BfsFgZVM))

This is a bug with `LongAnim_UpdateVariables` in [engine/anim_hp_bar.asm](engine/anim_hp_bar.asm):

```
	; This routine is buggy. The result from ComputeHPBarPixels is stored
	; in e. However, the pop de opcode deletes this result before it is even
	; used. The game then proceeds as though it never deleted that output.
	; To fix, uncomment the line below.
	call ComputeHPBarPixels
	; ld a, e
	pop bc
	pop de
	pop hl
	ld a, e ; Comment or delete this line to fix the above bug.
	ld hl, wCurHPBarPixels
	cp [hl]
	jr z, .loop
	ld [hl], a
	and a
	ret
```

**Fix:** Move `ld a, e` to right after `call ComputeHPBarPixels`.


## Experience underflow for level 1 Pokémon with Medium-Slow growth rate

([Video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXH8u0plHrE))

This can bring Pokémon straight from level 1 to 100 by gaining just a few experience points.

This is a bug with `CalcExpAtLevel` in [main.asm](main.asm):

```
CalcExpAtLevel: ; 50e47
; (a/b)*n**3 + c*n**2 + d*n - e
	ld a, [BaseGrowthRate]
	add a
	add a
	ld c, a
	ld b, 0
	ld hl, GrowthRates
	add hl, bc
```

**Fix:**

```
CalcExpAtLevel: ; 50e47
; (a/b)*n**3 + c*n**2 + d*n - e
	ld a, d
	cp 1
	jr nz, .UseExpFormula
; Pokémon have 0 experience at level 1
	xor a
	ld hl, hProduct
	ld [hli], a
	ld [hli], a
	ld [hli], a
	ld [hl], a
	ret

.UseExpFormula
	ld a, [BaseGrowthRate]
	add a
	add a
	ld c, a
	ld b, 0
	ld hl, GrowthRates
	add hl, bc
```


## Five-digit experience gain is printed incorrectly

([Video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o54VjpAEoO8))

This is a bug with `Text_ABoostedStringBuffer2ExpPoints` and `Text_StringBuffer2ExpPoints` in [text/common_2.asm](text/common_2.asm):

```
Text_ABoostedStringBuffer2ExpPoints::
	text ""
	line "a boosted"
	cont "@"
	deciram StringBuffer2, 2, 4
	text " EXP. Points!"
	prompt

Text_StringBuffer2ExpPoints::
	text ""
	line "@"
	deciram StringBuffer2, 2, 4
	text " EXP. Points!"
	prompt
```

**Fix:** Change `deciram StringBuffer2, 2, 4` to `deciram StringBuffer2, 2, 5`.


## Present damage is incorrect in link battles

([Video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XJaQoKtrEuw))

This bug existed for all battles in Gold and Silver, and was only fixed for single-player battles in Crystal to preserve link compatibility.

This is a bug with `BattleCommand_Present` in [battle/effects/present.asm](battle/effects/present.asm):

```
BattleCommand_Present: ; 37874
; present

	ld a, [wLinkMode]
	cp LINK_COLOSSEUM
	jr z, .colosseum_skippush
	push bc
	push de
.colosseum_skippush

	call BattleCommand_Stab

	ld a, [wLinkMode]
	cp LINK_COLOSSEUM
	jr z, .colosseum_skippop
	pop de
	pop bc
.colosseum_skippop
```

**Fix:**

```
BattleCommand_Present: ; 37874
; present

	push bc
	push de
	call BattleCommand_Stab
	pop de
	pop bc
```


## BRN/PSN/PAR do not affect catch rate

This is a bug with `PokeBall` in [items/item_effects.asm](items/item_effects.asm):

```
.statuscheck
; This routine is buggy. It was intended that SLP and FRZ provide a higher
; catch rate than BRN/PSN/PAR, which in turn provide a higher catch rate than
; no status effect at all. But instead, it makes BRN/PSN/PAR provide no
; benefit.
; Uncomment the line below to fix this.
	ld b, a
	ld a, [EnemyMonStatus]
	and 1 << FRZ | SLP
	ld c, 10
	jr nz, .addstatus
	; ld a, [EnemyMonStatus]
	and a
	ld c, 5
	jr nz, .addstatus
	ld c, 0
.addstatus
	ld a, b
	add c
	jr nc, .max_1
	ld a, $ff
.max_1
```

**Fix:** Uncomment `ld a, [EnemyMonStatus]`.


## Moon Ball does not boost catch rate

This is a bug with `MoonBallMultiplier` in [items/item_effects.asm](items/item_effects.asm):

```
MoonBallMultiplier:
; This function is buggy.
; Intent:  multiply catch rate by 4 if mon evolves with moon stone
; Reality: no boost

...

; Moon Stone's constant from Pokémon Red is used.
; No Pokémon evolve with Burn Heal,
; so Moon Balls always have a catch rate of 1×.
	push bc
	ld a, BANK(EvosAttacks)
	call GetFarByte
	cp MOON_STONE_RED ; BURN_HEAL
	pop bc
	ret nz
```

**Fix:** Change `MOON_STONE_RED` to `MOON_STONE`.


## Love Ball boosts catch rate for the wrong gender

This is a bug with `LoveBallMultiplier` in [items/item_effects.asm](items/item_effects.asm):

```
LoveBallMultiplier:
; This function is buggy.
; Intent:  multiply catch rate by 8 if mons are of same species, different sex
; Reality: multiply catch rate by 8 if mons are of same species, same sex

...

	ld a, d
	pop de
	cp d
	pop bc
	ret nz ; for the intended effect, this should be "ret z"
```

**Fix:** Change `ret nz` to `ret z`.


## Fast Ball only boosts catch rate for three Pokémon

This is a bug with `FastBallMultiplier` in [items/item_effects.asm](items/item_effects.asm):

```
FastBallMultiplier:
; This function is buggy.
; Intent:  multiply catch rate by 4 if enemy mon is in one of the three
;          FleeMons tables.
; Reality: multiply catch rate by 4 if enemy mon is one of the first three in
;          the first FleeMons table.

...

	inc hl
	cp -1
	jr z, .next
	cp c
	jr nz, .next ; for the intended effect, this should be "jr nz, .loop"
	sla b
	jr c, .max
```

**Fix:** Change `jr nz, .next` to `jr nz, .loop`.


## Friend Ball catches sent to the PC overwrite the wrong Pokémon's happiness

This is a bug with `PokeBall` in [items/item_effects.asm](items/item_effects.asm):

```
	ld a, [CurItem]
	cp FRIEND_BALL
	jr nz, .SkipBoxMonFriendBall
	; Bug: overwrites the happiness of the first mon in the box!
	ld a, FRIEND_BALL_HAPPINESS
	ld [sBoxMon1Happiness], a
.SkipBoxMonFriendBall:
```

`sBoxMon1Happiness` is written *before* the Friend Ball Pokémon is deposited.


## Dragon Scale. not Dragon Fang, boosts Dragon-type moves

This is a bug with `ItemAttributes` in [items/item_attributes.asm](items/item_attributes.asm):

```
; DRAGON FANG
	item_attribute 100, 0, 0, CANT_SELECT, ITEM, ITEMMENU_NOUSE, ITEMMENU_NOUSE

...

; DRAGON SCALE
	item_attribute 2100, HELD_DRAGON_BOOST, 10, CANT_SELECT, ITEM, ITEMMENU_NOUSE, ITEMMENU_NOUSE
```

**Fix:** Move `HELD_DRAGON_BOOST` to the `DRAGON FANG` attributes and `0` to `DRAGON SCALE`.


## Daisy's massages don't always increase happiness

This is a bug with `MassageOrHaircut` in [event/special.asm](event/special.asm):

```
; Bug: Subtracting $ff from $ff fails to set c.
; This can result in overflow into the next data array.
; In the case of getting a massage from Daisy, we bleed
; into CopyPokemonName_Buffer1_Buffer3, which passes
; $d0 to ChangeHappiness and returns $73 to the script.
; The end result is that there is a 0.4% chance your
; Pokemon's happiness will not change at all.
.loop
	sub [hl]
	jr c, .ok
	inc hl
	inc hl
	inc hl
	jr .loop

.ok
	inc hl
	ld a, [hli]
	ld [ScriptVar], a
	ld c, [hl]
	call ChangeHappiness
	ret

...

Data_DaisyMassage: ; 746b
	db $ff, 2, HAPPINESS_MASSAGE ; 99.6% chance

CopyPokemonName_Buffer1_Buffer3: ; 746e
	ld hl, StringBuffer1
	ld de, StringBuffer3
	ld bc, PKMN_NAME_LENGTH
	jp CopyBytes
```

**Fix:**

```
Data_DaisyMassage: ; 746b
	db $80, 2, HAPPINESS_MASSAGE ; 50% chance
	db $ff, 2, HAPPINESS_MASSAGE ; 50% chance
```


## No bump noise if standing on tile `$3E`

This is a bug with `DoPlayerMovement.CheckWarp` in [engine/player_movement.asm](engine/player_movement.asm):

```
; Bug: Since no case is made for STANDING here, it will check
; [.edgewarps + $ff]. This resolves to $3e at $8035a.
; This causes wd041 to be nonzero when standing on tile $3e,
; making bumps silent.

	ld a, [WalkingDirection]
	ld e, a
	ld d, 0
	ld hl, .EdgeWarps
	add hl, de
	ld a, [PlayerStandingTile]
	cp [hl]
	jr nz, .not_warp

	ld a, 1
	ld [wd041], a
	ld a, [WalkingDirection]
	cp STANDING
	jr z, .not_warp
```

**Fix:**

```
	ld a, [WalkingDirection]
	cp STANDING
	jr z, .not_warp
	ld e, a
	ld d, 0
	ld hl, .EdgeWarps
	add hl, de
	ld a, [PlayerStandingTile]
	cp [hl]
	jr nz, .not_warp

	ld a, 1
	ld [wd041], a
	ld a, [WalkingDirection]
```


## `CheckOwnMon` only checks the first five letters of OT names

([Video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GVTTmReM4nQ))

This bug can allow you to talk to Eusine in Celadon City and encounter Ho-Oh with only traded legendary beasts.

[engine/search.asm](engine/search.asm):

```
; check OT
; This only checks five characters, which is fine for the Japanese version,
; but in the English version the player name is 7 characters, so this is wrong.

	ld hl, PlayerName

rept PLAYER_NAME_LENGTH_JAPANESE - 1 ; should be PLAYER_NAME_LENGTH - 1
	ld a, [de]
	cp [hl]
	jr nz, .notfound
	cp "@"
	jr z, .found ; reached end of string
	inc hl
	inc de
endr

	ld a, [de]
	cp [hl]
	jr z, .found

.notfound
	pop de
	pop hl
	pop bc
	and a
	ret
```

**Fix:** Change `rept PLAYER_NAME_LENGTH_JAPANESE - 1` to `rept PLAYER_NAME_LENGTH - 1`.


## `HELD_CATCH_CHANCE` has no effect

This is a bug with `PokeBall` in [items/item_effects.asm](items/item_effects.asm):

```
	; BUG: callba overwrites a,
	; and GetItemHeldEffect takes b anyway.

	; This is probably the reason
	; the HELD_CATCH_CHANCE effect
	; is never used.

	; Uncomment the line below to fix.

	ld a, [BattleMonItem]
;	ld b, a
	callba GetItemHeldEffect
	ld a, b
	cp HELD_CATCH_CHANCE
```

**Fix:** Uncomment `ld b, a`.


## `ScriptCall` can overflow `wScriptStack` and crash

[engine/scripting.asm](engine/scripting.asm):

```
ScriptCall:
; Bug: The script stack has a capacity of 5 scripts, yet there is
; nothing to stop you from pushing a sixth script.  The high part
; of the script address can then be overwritten by modifications
; to ScriptDelay, causing the script to return to the rst/interrupt
; space.

	push de
	ld hl, wScriptStackSize
	ld e, [hl]
	inc [hl]
	ld d, $0
	ld hl, wScriptStack
	add hl, de
	add hl, de
	add hl, de
	pop de
	ld a, [ScriptBank]
	ld [hli], a
	ld a, [ScriptPos]
	ld [hli], a
	ld a, [ScriptPos + 1]
	ld [hl], a
	ld a, b
	ld [ScriptBank], a
	ld a, e
	ld [ScriptPos], a
	ld a, d
	ld [ScriptPos + 1], a
	ret
```


## `LoadSpriteGFX` does not limit the capacity of `UsedSprites`

[engine/overworld.asm](engine/overworld.asm):

```
LoadSpriteGFX: ; 14306
; Bug: b is not preserved, so
; it's useless as a next count.

	ld hl, UsedSprites
	ld b, SPRITE_GFX_LIST_CAPACITY
.loop
	ld a, [hli]
	and a
	jr z, .done
	push hl
	call .LoadSprite
	pop hl
	ld [hli], a
	dec b
	jr nz, .loop

.done
	ret

.LoadSprite:
	call GetSprite
	ld a, l
	ret
; 1431e
```

`GetSprite` modifies `b`. Surround it with `push bc`/`pop bc` to fix.


## `ChooseWildEncounter` doesn't really validate the wild Pokémon species

[engine/wildmons.asm](engine/wildmons.asm):

```
ChooseWildEncounter: ; 2a14f
...

	ld a, b
	ld [CurPartyLevel], a
	ld b, [hl]
	; ld a, b
	call ValidateTempWildMonSpecies
	jr c, .nowildbattle

	ld a, b ; This is in the wrong place.
	cp UNOWN
	jr nz, .done

...

ValidateTempWildMonSpecies: ; 2a4a0
; Due to a development oversight, this function is called with the wild Pokemon's level, not its species, in a.
```

**Fix:**

```
	ld a, b
	ld [CurPartyLevel], a
	ld b, [hl]
	ld a, b
	call ValidateTempWildMonSpecies
	jr c, .nowildbattle

	cp UNOWN
	jr nz, .done
```

## `TryObjectEvent` arbitrary code execution

[engine/events.asm](engine/events.asm):

```
; Bug: If IsInArray returns nc, data at bc will be executed as code.
	push bc
	ld de, 3
	ld hl, .pointers
	call IsInArray
	jr nc, .nope_bugged
	pop bc

	inc hl
	ld a, [hli]
	ld h, [hl]
	ld l, a
	jp hl

.nope_bugged
	; pop bc
	xor a
	ret
```

**Fix:** Uncomment `pop bc`.


## `Special_CheckBugContestContestantFlag` can read beyond its data table

[event/bug_contest_2.asm](event/bug_contest_2.asm):

```
Special_CheckBugContestContestantFlag: ; 139ed
; Checks the flag of the Bug Catching Contestant whose index is loaded in a.

; Bug: If a >= 10 when this is called, it will read beyond the table.

	ld hl, BugCatchingContestantEventFlagTable
	ld e, a
	ld d, 0
	add hl, de
	add hl, de
	ld e, [hl]
	inc hl
	ld d, [hl]
	ld b, CHECK_FLAG
	call EventFlagAction
	ret
; 139fe

BugCatchingContestantEventFlagTable: ; 139fe
	dw EVENT_BUG_CATCHING_CONTESTANT_1A
	dw EVENT_BUG_CATCHING_CONTESTANT_2A
	dw EVENT_BUG_CATCHING_CONTESTANT_3A
	dw EVENT_BUG_CATCHING_CONTESTANT_4A
	dw EVENT_BUG_CATCHING_CONTESTANT_5A
	dw EVENT_BUG_CATCHING_CONTESTANT_6A
	dw EVENT_BUG_CATCHING_CONTESTANT_7A
	dw EVENT_BUG_CATCHING_CONTESTANT_8A
	dw EVENT_BUG_CATCHING_CONTESTANT_9A
	dw EVENT_BUG_CATCHING_CONTESTANT_10A
; 13a12
```


## `ClearWRAM` only clears WRAM bank 1

[home/init.asm](home/init.asm):

```
ClearWRAM:: ; 25a
; Wipe swappable WRAM banks (1-7)
; Assumes CGB or AGB

	ld a, 1
.bank_loop
	push af
	ld [rSVBK], a
	xor a
	ld hl, $d000
	ld bc, $1000
	call ByteFill
	pop af
	inc a
	cp 8
	jr nc, .bank_loop ; Should be jr c
	ret
; 270
```

**Fix:** Change `jr nc, .bank_loop` to `jr c, .bank_loop`.